Mets First Base Problem: Stearns Must Find a Solution

The Mets Have a First Base Problem. David Stearns Needs to Fix It. One of the biggest needs this offseason for the New York Mets besides pitching is probably first…

Silhouette of NY Mets player fielding in shadow.

The Mets Have a First Base Problem. David Stearns Needs to Fix It.

One of the biggest needs this offseason for the New York Mets besides pitching is probably first base. The New York Mets have spent enough time trying to figure out who belongs at first base. It’s time to stop experimenting and find an actual solution.

Replacing Pete Alonso was never going to be easy. The Polar Bear was one of the most productive power hitters in franchise history, and replacing his home runs, run production and presence in the lineup was always going to require a serious effort.

Unfortunately, the Mets attempt to replace him during the 2026 season was a disappointment. Stearns losing Alonso might be one of his biggest mistakes.

Jorge Polanco never became the answer. Mark Vientos failed to establish himself as a dependable option. Jared Young provided some encouraging moments, but expecting him to carry the position for an entire season is asking a lot.

Now, heading into 2027, the Mets have another opportunity to address the problem.

They cannot afford to get this wrong again. 

Jared Young Deserves a Chance, But He Isn’t the Answer by Himself

There is one positive from the Mets’ first-base situation: Jared Young showed that he can contribute.

Young hit .266 with a .330 on-base percentage, a .429 slugging percentage and nine home runs in 103 games during 2026. He also demonstrated that he can be productive against right-handed pitching, posting a .793 OPS.

That’s encouraging.

But there’s another side to the story.

Young posted just a .606 OPS against left-handed pitching. Those numbers suggest he would be better suited for a platoon arrangement rather than being handed the everyday job.

That’s perfectly fine.

Young doesn’t have to be the problem. The problem would be the Mets convincing themselves that his emergence means they don’t need to acquire another first baseman.

They do.

Keep Young involved. Give him opportunities against right-handed pitching. Let him contribute to the lineup.

But bring in somebody who can handle the other side of the platoon and provide the offensive production this team desperately needs.

The Bystander Take

There doesn’t seem to be a first baseman in the Mets pipeline. Internationally, the free agents available don’t play first. Unless a trade happens, the Mets will be looking to free agency. 

I’m personally not a huge fan of trades. Not saying, that can’t be an option. But who are the Mets trading? Vientos? Senga?

What kind of return do you get for them? 

As for free agency, rumors point to Ty France and Alec Bohm. Neither player excites me. Actually, the free agent class at first base seems weak to me. 

Last season Ty France had a good offensive year. He’s done similar in the past, but he’s been inconsistent throughout his career. He’s also not that good of a defender at first. I also think you’d be paying a lot for a little return with France. 

Bohm played first base towards the end of last season and was average at best defensively. Offensively, he’s below average in my opinion and not a long-term solution. 

If we’re talking about letting Young platoon at first (which doesn’t seem like a horrible idea), then I think the Mets should target Paul Goldschmidt. 

Paul Goldschmidt, first baseman with the New York Yankees during an interview for YES Network before a game against the Milwaukee Brewers on March 30, 2025.

Look at the positives:

While money isn’t an issue, Goldy is cheap. Last year he signed a 1 year deal for $4 million. 

He’s a 4 time gold glover. Although his overall production has declined, Goldschmidt still demonstrated that he can provide defensive value at first base.  According to Baseball Savant, his Outs Above Average (OAA) last year was a 6. 

Paul is also a right-handed batter, so he fits perfectly into the platoon role.

The Mets only played 49 games versus left-handed starters last year. So the bulk of the games would go to Young.

Last season, in 105 games Goldschmidt hit .252, with a .752 OPS, and 18 homers. However, in 81 games versus left-handed pitching, he raked. 11 of his home runs were off of Lefties. He hit .299, a SLG of .573, and an OPS of .967.

Personally, I think this is the best move. Again, unless a trade happens somewhere, I say wait until the 2028 Free Agency class comes around. At the moment, you potentially have some big names coming out at first base: (while aging) Freddie Freeman, Yandy Diaz, and Willson Contreras. 

The names that do get me excited are Andrew Vaughn and Munetake Murakami. I think the White Sox will be too cheap to pay Murakami. So they’ll either trade him or let him go to free agency.

What do you think the Mets should do at first base?

The Bystander

Closely Observing the Mets


Discover more from Bystander Sports

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from Bystander Sports

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading