MLB Pick-Your-Opponent Playoff Proposal Explained (Plus Why Seeds 1 & 3 Select Their Matchups)

MLB Pick-Your-Opponent Playoff Proposal Explained (Plus Why Seeds 1 & 3 Select Their Matchups) Last week, Major League Baseball made their latest proposal to the MLB Players Association presenting a…

Major League Baseball logo with white batter silhouette on blue and red background, MLB text below on white.

MLB Pick-Your-Opponent Playoff Proposal Explained (Plus Why Seeds 1 & 3 Select Their Matchups)

Major League Baseball logo with white batter silhouette on blue and red background, MLB text below on white.

Last week, Major League Baseball made their latest proposal to the MLB Players Association presenting a major structural overhaul to both the regular season and the postseason. 

Beyond shifting to a 154 game schedule to create built-in weekly “off” days, the league is aiming to revamp October baseball by expanding the Division Series from a best-of-five to a best-of-seven format and introducing an opponent selection feature. 

Under this “pick-your-opponent” format, the top seed in each league would choose their Division Series match-up from the Wild Card winners, while the No. 3 seed would choose their Wild Card opponent, creating high-stakes drama and built-in rivalries. 

To explain why the first and third seed pick their opponent and second seed does not. Here is why:

Under MLB’s playoff structure, the top two seeds (No. 1 and No. 2) earn a first-round bye straight into the Division Series. Because they don’t play during the opening weekend, they don’t need a Wild Card opponent. 

Here is why the No. 3 seed gets to pick instead: 

They are the highest-ranked team actually playing in the Wild Card Series. As the lowest-ranked division winner, the No. 3 seed lacks a top-two record to earn a bye, but holds a higher seed than seeds 4, 5, and 6. To reward them for winning their division, MLB gives them the right to select their opponent from the lowest seeds (No. 5 vs. No. 6). 

In the Division Series round, both the No. 1 and No. 2 seeds enter the action. However, only the No. 1 seed gets to pick which of the two Wild Card Series winners it wants to play. The No. 2 seed automatically plays whichever Wild Card winner is left over. 

Major Sticking Point

However, the entire package remains a major sticking point in labor negotiations because owners have made every scheduling and playoff change contingent on the union agreeing to a salary cap and floor system. 

The MLBPA has historically opposed a hard salary cap, viewing it as a mechanism that artificially restricts player earning potential and free agency value. By bundling fan friendly playoff changes and a shorter regular season with payroll restrictions, the league is using structural modernization as leverage to achieve the economic guardrails it has sought for decades. 

See the other major disparities in MLB CBA our article.

The Bystander

Closely Observing Major League Baseball


Discover more from Bystander Sports

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Discover more from Bystander Sports

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading