David Stearns: Why Mets Fans Should Trust His Plan

David Stearns’ Blueprint for Building a Winner: Why Mets Fans Should Believe in His Approach  David Stearns won’t get a World Series ring but his fingerprints are all over the…

text that says: bystander sports presents: david stearns' blueprint for building a winner. to the right of text an ai image of david stearns with citi field in the background
bystander sports bs logo in bottom right corner

David Stearns’ Blueprint for Building a Winner: Why Mets Fans Should Believe in His Approach 

David Stearns won’t get a World Series ring but his fingerprints are all over the Commissioner’s Trophy. For New York Mets fans, that should be a very encouraging development.

The Milwaukee Brewers just won the 2026 World Series, defeating the Tampa Bay Rays in five games to capture the first championship in franchise history. While Stearns was no longer running Milwaukee when the Brewers won it all, the foundation of that championship team was built during his time leading the organization. 

That’s something Mets fans should be noticing and excited about for the future of the franchise.

Stearns served as Milwaukee’s General Manager from 2015 through 2019 before becoming President of Baseball Operations in 2019 to 2022. He eventually left Milwaukee to take the same leadership position with the Mets in 2023.

His track record in Milwaukee provides plenty of reasons to believe he can help bring a championship to Queens.

Here are several reasons Mets fans should be happy David Stearns is running the baseball operations department.

How David Stearns Helped Build a World Series Champion in Milwaukee 

The biggest reason for Mets fans to feel optimistic is simple: look at Milwaukee.

Milwaukee built a significant portion of its roster through scouting, drafting, international signings, player development, and smart acquisitions.

Stearns was instrumental in establishing that organizational approach.

He understood that a smaller market organization couldn’t simply compete by spending the most money. It needed to identify talent, develop players, make smart trades, and continually replenish its roster.

The 2026 Brewers are an excellent example of what that philosophy can produce.

Mets fans should recognize the significance of that. New York has financial resources that Milwaukee doesn’t. Imagine what a baseball executive with Stearns’ organizational philosophy can accomplish with the resources available to the Mets.

Why Player Development Is Central to His Philosophy 

background is a blueprint to the right is ai image of david stearns. at the top, says bystander sports presents. then to the left of david stearns in bold text player development is central to david stearns philosophy. 
bystander sports bs logo in bottom right corner

Something that stands out when looking at Milwaukee’s roster is the number of players who developed within the organization. 

Stearns and his baseball operations department helped build Milwaukee’s pipeline of young talent through scouting, drafting, international signings, and trades. 

Look at this impressive list: 

Pitchers:

Aaron Ashby, Robert Gasser, Logan Henderson, Jacob Misiorowski, and Abner Uribe.

Position Players:

Jackson Chourio, Sal Frelick, Luis Lara, Garrett Mitchell, Christian Yelich, David Hamilton, and Brice Turang.

Henderson, Ashby, and Misiorowski were all drafted outside of the first round. 

Misiorowski is perhaps the most impressive example on this list. A second-round selection who developed into one of baseball’s most dominant starting pitchers is exactly the kind of result an organization wants from its scouting and development departments. 

How David Stearns Has Reshaped the New York Mets 

Under the leadership of David Stearns, the organization shifted its primary philosophy toward building a sustainable, homegrown talent pipeline rather than relying exclusively on high cost external free agency. 

Stearns has emphasized improving the Mets’ player development infrastructure, including pitching development, biomechanics, pitch design, and analytical tools. The goal is to give the organization more ways to identify, develop, and improve talent. 

Early importance was placed on reshaping the minor league and developmental systems, highlighted by hiring Andy Green to oversee player development and bridge the gap between emerging prospects and the major league roster. 

After Carlos Mendoza was fired, Andy took over as interim manager. He is now officially Manager of the New York Mets. 

Simultaneously, the front office expanded its international scouting operations under Director James Kang and Assistant Director Laiky Uribe. 

By bolstering global amateur scouting alongside domestic player development, the franchise established the infrastructure needed to secure a steady, continuous influx of elite young talent.

It’s way too early to see what will come from the international players the Mets have signed during David Stearns’ tenure. Same for the players that have been drafted but time will tell.

At this year’s trade deadline, Stearns kept the organization’s future in mind by trading major league players in exchange for prospects. 

Evaluating Stearns’ First Three Seasons in Queens 

Owner Steve Cohen had unsuccessfully tried to pry Stearns away from the Brewers before his contract was up. However, on October 2nd, 2023 David Stearns officially signed with the Mets as their President of Baseball Operations. He signed a five year contract. 

As Mets fans, we know how the seasons ended during his tenure; no world series. 

But let’s recap what happened but before we do, let’s remember, there is a business side to baseball. 

2023 Offseason:

During the 2023 season, the Mets had the highest payroll in baseball at over $376 million dollars according to Spotrac. They sold off before the trade deadline finishing with a 75-87 record. 

The Mets were still responsible for a significant portion of those contracts even after trading the players away. Which left Stearns with expensive financial commitments he inherited from the previous administration. 

When David took over, they seemed to pivot away from massive long-term spending toward shorter, moderate deals. Signing: Sean Manaea (2 years – $28 Million), Luis Severino (1 year – $13 Million), Harrison Bader (1 year – $10.5 Million), Joey Wendle (1 year – $1.9 Million).

What happened in the 2024 season? Magic happened! 

A slow start, 22-33 through May 29th. Then a players only meeting, Grimace made an appearance, and the OMG anthem completely changed the Mets season. 

They clinched the NL Wild Card in game 161 (first game of a double header) where Lindor hit a 2-run homer in the 9th inning to give New York the lead. 

They finished with an 89-73 record. New York then went on to the NLCS where they lost to the Dodgers in six games. 

2024 Offseason:

After year one, I think Mets fans were extremely happy and it set the bar high. I also personally think that David Stearns got a little too eager with Uncle Steve’s money. 

Diving into a historic offseason of spending, by signing Juan Soto to a record $765 million contract over fifteen years. Along with re-signing Sean Manaea (3 years – $75 million), and Pete Alonso (2 years – $54 million). 

Outside of the historic Juan Soto contract, Stearns continued to favor shorter-term contracts with relatively high average annual values (AAV). 

They went from the 3rd highest payroll in baseball to the highest for the 2025 season because of Soto’s record breaking deal. 

Do you remember the 2025 season? 

The excitement of having Juan Soto. He would be the guy to put us over the hump, right? 

It was a tale of 2 halves. New York started off hot, 45-24 through June 12th. Then the collapse slowly began to happen. 

The Mets missed the Wild Card by losing the last game of the season to the Marlins. Cincinnati ended up making the playoffs because they owned the tiebreaker by winning the season series between the two teams. 

Disappointment in true Mets fashion. 

2025 Offseason:

After the debacle at the end of the season, Stearns seemed to do a complete overhaul, shaping the team into his own vision. Building around 2 core players, Lindor and Soto. 

He traded Nimmo to the Rangers in exchange for Semien and Jeff McNeil and cash to the Athletics for 17 year old prospect Yordan Rodriguez.

David also traded away prospects Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat for Freddy Peralta and Tobia Myers. 

Stearns also got Luis Robert Jr. from the White Sox for Luis Angel Acuna and Truman Pauley.

New York then acquired Devin Williams (3 years – $51 million), Luke Weaver (2 years – $22 million), Jorge Polanco (2 years – $40 million), and Bo Bichette (3 years – $126 million) through free agency. 

It’s important to remember that the Mets were building around just two established core players, Lindor and Soto. There were plenty of holes to fill, and Stearns had to work with the players and resources available. 

On paper, he appeared to have assembled a competitive roster heading into the season. 

The Eye Opening 2026 Season

With the 2nd highest payroll in baseball, the Mets looked completely different with a lot of question marks but high hopes. 

Then the season started and they fell flat, losing twelve games in a row and starting the season 7-19.

Lindor and Soto both had injuries that totaled about 2 months a piece. Then Polanco got hurt and Peralta never played as expected. 

Carlos Mendoza was eventually fired midseason, and interim manager Andy Green took over. 

On a positive note, the Mets looked better in the second half of the season. They did find some other bright spots in the Rookies Nolan McLean, Carson Benge, and A.J. Ewing. 

The moves made by David seemed to be largely correct. Stearns improved the team’s defensive stability up the middle and addressed some of the roster’s previous weaknesses. 

However, some moves created new questions, particularly at first base. Not every roster decision worked out as planned. 

The Current Offseason:

The Offseason officially began October 29th, 2026. There is an exclusive 5 day window for impending free agents to negotiate with their current team. If no agreement is reached, they are allowed to sign with any team. 

Due to the fire sale this past season, the Mets have no impending free agents. 

However, the Mets have 10 players eligible for Arbitration this year. The date for salary arbitration isn’t until January. 

To learn more about what salary arbitration is, you can read the article “What is Salary Arbitration? A Complete Guide for Baseball Fans”.

This offseason will be extremely interesting to see what happens. The current collective bargaining agreement expires on December 1st, and a lockout is expected to begin on December 2nd if a new agreement isn’t reached. 

You can read more about approaching lockout and what the major disagreements are for the new Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) in the article “The MLB CBA and the New York Mets: How the 2026 Labor Negotiations Could Affect the Mets”.

Recently, this offseason, the Mets claimed Kyren Paris off waivers and DFA’d Cristian Pache to make roster space. 

The Bystander Take: Why I Still Trust David Stearns 

black background. 
patch top says "in stearns we trust" new york city skyline with seams at a baseball at top forming a circle at bottom laurel wreath
bystander sports bs logo in bottom right corner

Stearns frequently speaks about “maximizing probability over time,” managing long term franchise health alongside immediate playoff odds, and maintaining organizational flexibility rather than locking the team into high risk, multi-year contracts for aging starters. 

I like this philosophy, it allows you to move on or dump bad contracts quickly without expensive repercussions like when Eppler was in office. 

Personally, I was never a huge fan of Mendoza as the New York Mets manager. While the Mets made the playoffs in 2024, I think they underachieved by not winning the division. 

In my opinion, poor in-game management by Carlos Mendoza was one of the largest reasons the Mets missed the playoffs in 2025. 

The Mets also underperformed in 2026 mainly due to Carlos Mendoza and David Stearns waiting too long to fire him. Just to be clear, I don’t think Mendoza was the only reason, just the main reason.

As far as what David Stearns has done from a prospect standpoint, he was in office when the Mets drafted future Superstar Carson Benge. 

This offseason will be interesting especially with the impending lockout. I have high hopes for the Mets in 2027. It will be a shame because it will probably be marred by missed games.

David Stearns hasn’t been perfect in New York, and the Mets have certainly given their fans reasons to be frustrated. However, building a championship organization takes more than signing big name free agents. 

It requires player development, smart roster construction, organizational depth, and the ability to continually replenish talent. Stearns has demonstrated that he understands those principles while in Milwaukee. To me, he is demonstrating that he can bring those same results to Queens.

I trust what David is doing, so let him cook.

The Bystander

Closely Observing the Mets Front Office


Discover more from Bystander Sports

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from Bystander Sports

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading